Fact Check: Medicare Is Not Free For Undocumented Immigrants

A Facebook post went viral in the U.S. for claiming that illegal immigrants are enjoying the benefits of Medicare and Medicare Supplements for free, while seniors who are legal residents continue to pay for their policies. The claim was published on the Columbian Post’s social media page on February 1, 2019 had been shared over 14,000 times and garnered almost 300 comments as at March 4.

The problem was: the information is totally false. While the Columbian Post’s “About Page” says that it is a growing paper that does not report fake news, its viral post has led other fact checkers to verify the truth to its claim. So here we are, laying out the facts on who is truly eligible for Medicare and if undocumented immigrants are really enjoying benefits that documented seniors are getting.

Eligibility for Medicare

According to the Social Security Administration, to become entitled to Premium-Health Insurance (Premium-HI), an individual should be as follows:

  • 65 years old
  • A resident of the United States as a) citizen, or b) an alien who has been legally admitted for permanent residence and has lived in the country continuously for five years immediately before the month all other requirements are fulfilled.
  • Eligible for health insurance under any other provision
  • Have an existing Supplement Medical Insurance (SMI) coverage or eligible for SMI enrollment, and
  • Having filed an application for HI during a set enrollment period.

There is no provision that allows undocumented immigrants to be eligible for either Social Security or Medicare. What is provided is HI for immigrants who are legally residing in the U.S. under specific conditions.

This eligibility list is further supported by two government documents that both state that those who live in the country illegally are not at all eligible for healthcare benefits.

1. Program Operations Manual System for Social Security, and

2. a document from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.

CMS’ document explicitly states that Medicare and Medicare Supplements are only for legal residents aged 65 years old and up, legal residents younger than 65 years but have certain qualifying disabilities, and legal residents of any age who have been diagnosed with End-Stage Renal Disease (ESRD).

So where does the viral Facebook post’s claim come from? It perhaps springs from misinformation and lack of understanding of U.S. government health care guidelines.

Who Pays for Medicare and Who Gets It for Free?

Medicare has several parts, with Part A covering inpatient care insurance and Part B covering outpatient care. Eligible individuals typically do not need to pay for Part A, but they are required to pay for Part B if they want to have it.

Part B is insurance that takes care of doctor visits, medically-necessary durable medical equipment, medically-necessary drugs administered in an outpatient setting. An immigrant who is legally residing in the U.S. and who has met all conditions for health insurance is eligible for Part B. Undocumented immigrants do not have access to it.

Special Enrollment Period for New U.S. Citizens

If you are a new legal U.S. citizen, you are granted a Special Enrollment Period for federal health care services. New citizens are given 60 days from the day they were granted legal status to sign up. Take note that the Medicare program is only available to those who have been legally residing in the country for five years continuously.

How Do Illegal Immigrants Access Health Care Services?

Undocumented immigrants are allowed to get Medicaid in an EMERGENCY situation and even this covers a limited list of urgent and emergent services. Federal law, via the EMTALA provision, requires Medicare-affiliated hospitals to provide stabilization and screening services to anybody who walks into the emergency room without having to consider their residency status or insurance. There is no Medicare or Medicare Supplement program for these individuals.

In 2014, even the Obama Administration said that undocumented immigrants should not be granted access into Medicare rosters, though some states have created their own programs that would cater to illegal immigrants, particularly children and/or pregnant women. These include California, New York and Oregon.

What Health Care Assistance Is Available to the Undocumented?

If the undocumented immigrant is low-income and is unable to pay for Medicare services, some states offer short-term health insurance programs that are specific to their needs and capacity to pay. While this comes with an out-of-pocket expense, it is far better than not being insured at all. These short-term policies are not provided through the health insurance exchanges, so the usual requirement of a proof of legal status does not apply. The coverage is less comprehensive and will likely not consider pre-existing health conditions. However, it will be of great help to those who are healthy. Because they are not sold through exchanges, it is best to read the fine print per policy first before signing up.

States offer different levels of special coverage for the undocumented so it’s best to check what are being provided and what are not included in the area where one lives. These short-term programs are also not regulated by federal law, except that their term should have a maximum of 364 days, with the total length of coverage limited to 36 months including renewals. Some states offer a three-month limit, while others allow the maximum number of days with a limit of three renewals. Other states do not provide this at all.

Number of Illegal Immigrants in the United States

Accord to Kaiser Family Foundation, there are around 3.6 million illegal immigrants among the population of uninsured people in the country as of December 2017. The number of undocumented immigrants who are uninsured is significantly higher than U.S. citizens with no insurance.

Correcting The False Claim

Outside of these, according to the New York Times, certain illegal immigrants were able to receive benefits due to a glitch in the process and Medicare’s failure to carry out limitations that Congress had mandated.

There have been several holes in the system that were abused thereafter, but those were errors that did not mean undocumented immigrants are already being given privileges exclusive to those who are in the country legally. For that reason and all the supporting evidence stated earlier, the Facebook post that went viral is certified false and should be corrected.

15 Costly Medicare Mistakes That Shouldn’t Happen to You

Medicare is a godsend for all Americans as it not only helps senior citizens cope with the expenses that come with aging, it also reduces the amount of financial stress on their families. Access to affordable healthcare products and services is a privilege that U.S. citizens are lucky to have because not all countries provide this level of care and assistance.

However, if you’re not careful and do not read the guidelines that govern this system of healthcare, you could also find yourself stressing over surcharges, penalties and other otherwise avoidable fees. This is why the government is extra vigilant in offering information via print resources and online about the rules that surround enrollment and availing of Medicare and related services. It is also our duty as citizens to keep ourselves informed of the rules and yearly updates and changes to make sure that we or those close to us get the most out of Medicare.

Why Medicare Is Important and Necessary

Simply put, Medicare is a guarantee that members will be able to afford health insurance. Before it was introduced, more than 50% of Americans had zero access to health services and had no choice but live with distress (and imminent death) when all illness struck. In the past, retirees either had to clean out their bank accounts, seek welfare, ask for financial help from children or relatives, or just make do without any care at all. Now, those who are enrolled even in basic Medicare coverage know that they can access a much wider range of products and services, not just for illnesses but also for general wellness.

Medicare is not free, except for Part A coverage. Part B ($135.50/month for 2019), Medicare Advantage (custom priced), Part D prescription drug coverage (minimum $33.19/month for 2019), and Medicare Supplements (Medigap, custom priced) all come with a monthly premium. However, these fees are significantly lower than what seniors would have had to pay in case an emergency happens or if they just want to consult with a doctor for whatever reason. The scope of benefits far outweighs the monthly cost.

In short, Medicare paves the way for everyone to have access to sound health care services for treatment, prevention and overall wellness purposes. Additionally, because it is regulated by the federal government, members can rest assured that they get the same quality services regardless where they get it anywhere in the country, with others even extending as far as enjoying emergency care coverage while traveling to another country (Medigap).

At this point, it is important to note that Medicare is not just for the senior members of society. It also covers disabled persons who are usually unable to get approved for regular insurance from private providers. Other conditions that qualify a person for Medicare coverage are end-stage renal disease (ESRD) and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS).

Costly Medicare Mistakes That You Should Watch Out For and Avoid

1. Delaying Part-B enrollment

When people hit the age of 65 but are still enjoying HMO coverage from their employment, they usually opt to skip enrolling to Medicare Part B and just sign up for Part A. This is to avoid having to pay a monthly premium for something that they won’t technically be using yet because the previous employer-provided insurance coverage still exists. While this sounds like a smart move, it might not be practical in the long-term.

There is practical wisdom in being doubly insured. Medicare will shoulder expenses first and let the private insurer cover the remainder in certain cases, or the it goes the other way. After all, it’s not like you will be staying in employment for a longer period, so it’s best to get Medicare bit done as scheduled to avoid any penalties later.

2. Not taking advantage of your initial enrollment period

Your Initial Enrollment Period is the best window to apply for Medicare Part B. This is the time when you are first eligible for coverage, during which you are given plenty of leeway. Would-be seniors have seven months to sign up for Part B. These include the three months before your 65th birthday, your birth month, and the three months after it.

By delaying your Part B enrollment, you will be subjected to a late-enrollment penalty, which is equivalent to 10%+ for every 12 months that you were eligible but did not enrol. You will be required to pay this higher monthly premium until you opt out of Medicare entirely, which means that you will be paying for it for the rest of your lifetime. The savings at the start is attractive, but surely you don’t want to pay higher fees in the long run.

3. Failing to plan in advance

Choosing the right Medicare plan means exercising foresight—as in “where do you see your health going in the next 5 to 10 years?” Remember that health insurance is preparation for something that still does not exist, so if your current health status predisposes you to certain types of illnesses, you might want to consider expanding beyond Part B and then signing up for Part D prescription drug coverage.

If you are healthy now but suspect you might not be in five years, signing up for a Medicare Supplement plan also helps you prepare. If you are not pre-armed with an illness does happen, you will have to pay for expenses out-of-pocket—and they will expensive.

4. Not signing up when you are first eligible

Because not everybody retires at 65, it’s easy to skip the period when you are first eligible and decide to worry about it later. There is truth to this: you don’t really need Medicare if you are still working at 65. However, related to 1 and 2 above, not only will you risk having to pay penalties and higher premiums, you could also get turned down (if you apply for Medicare Advantage or Medigap plans) if you do not meet medical underwriting requirements. In the end, you either pay more or pay for healthcare services and products out of pocket.

5. Signing up for a plan without studying their cost and benefits

Just going on ahead and signing up for a Medicare or Medigap plan just so it’s over and done with is a huge and potentially costly mistake. If you’re unsure about the benefits or do not understand the resources provided to you, it’s best to consult with a qualified Medicare or Medicare Supplement advisor so all your cards are laid out and everything is transparent. You might still opt for the priceyer plans, but at least you know what’s coming (and are prepared) when the bill arrives.

6. You have a Medicare Advantage plan but you went out of your network

If you opt for a Medicare Advantage plan, which is provided through a private insurance agency, you will need to limit your consultations and access services with the provider’s given network of doctors, clinics and hospitals. If you are in an area where there the network is thin, you might be forced to go outside the network for convenience—and that will mean out of pocket expenses and higher charges. That said, if Medicare Advantage is your preferred route, be sure that the private insurer you sign up with has a wide network that you take advantage of from anywhere.

7. Assuming that you are covered because your spouse is

If you had enjoyed healthcare coverage from your spouse who was previously employed, it is not the same with Medicare. Spouses will have to enroll as separate entities and pay their own premiums. Assuming that you are covered because your husband or wife already has Medicare means out of pocket expenses should a medical emergency happen or even if you just want to have a wellness exam from a local clinic.

8. Failing to enroll within eight months after leaving regular employment

This is a careless but very common mistake among those who did not sign up for Medicare at 65 because they are still employed. Note that you need to enroll within eight months after you resign from your job to avoid any headaches. Otherwise, you are left with no choice but to wait until the next enrollment window (January to March, with actual coverage not starting until July 1 of the same year). This means you are not covered at all during the gap—and this could translate to out of pocket expenses should a medical emergency arise.

9. Not monitoring your Part D plan yearly

Signing up for a Part D prescription drug coverage and then keeping it on autopilot year after year can spell additional costs on your part. First, Part D plans get updated and see changes annually, so the costs will vary. Some plans will have more expensive premiums as the years go by. Also, if you initially signed up for Part D for branded medications but then decided to go for generic products later, then you might want to switch to another type of plan.

10. Buying the same Part D plan as your spouse

Medicare Part D prescription drug coverage plans charge couples separately and will not give discounts for dual purchases. That said, it doesn’t make sense to have the same coverage as your significant other, especially as you don’t really need the same medicines. Otherwise, you end up paying for something you don’t get to use and don’t really require. Part D coverage should be according to your specific needs. Who knows, yours might be significantly cheaper than your spouse’s.

11. Not choosing the right and most appropriate Medicare Supplement plan

Purchasing a Medigap plan within six months after enrolling in Medicare Part B enables you to get any plan that’s available in your area without being subjected to any medical underwriting procedure. You are guaranteed the plan of your choice. However, if you find later on that the plan you selected is not for you and decide to switch, it could be costly. Insurance providers might charge you a higher premium, or reject your application altogether.

Some insurers allow you to switch plans without undergoing a new medical exam, while some states let you change regardless of your current health status—but this can’t be assumed for all states and companies. This is why it is very important to carefully study the benefits, coverage, and cost of the Medigap plan you choose from the beginning to avoid these expensive changes.

12. Assuming that Medicare covers all healthcare products and services

Note that Medicare does not coverage vision, hearing and dental needs, unless they are medically necessary for another procedure that it covers. That said, if you have such specific needs, you will want to sign up for a separate plan from private insurers to minimize your expenses as much as possible. Otherwise, you will be forced to pay for regular fees, most of which are not retiree-friendly.

13. Not signing up for Part B coverage if you have COBRA or retiree coverage

Medicare is 65 and up’s primary source of healthcare coverage, unless you haven’t retired yet and are still enjoying insurance provided by your current employer. However, there are other types of work-related insurance that will not provide the same level of coverage: severance packages, retiree and COBRA coverages are examples. If you have these and do not sign up for Medicare Part B when you turn 65, it can mean huge haps in your healthcare access PLUS late enrollment penalties that run for your entire lifetime.

14. You forgot to stop contributions to your Health Savings Account (HSA)

If you sign up for Medicare, you can no longer contribute to an HSA. Be careful about your contributions in the period you resigned from your current job and enrolled in Medicare, as your HSA payments should be prorated according to the number of months prior to Medicare coverage.

15. Not monitoring or spreading out your gross income, making you subject to higher surcharges

Getting old doesn’t stop you from still making investments and boosting your gross income, but if you forget to spread out your totals, you could end up paying more in surcharges for Medicare. For example, if your gross income changes midway, your Part D plan could switch from a monthly premium of $13 to a whopping $74.80 just like that. Financial experts recommend spreading Roth conversions over a few years or withdrawing your cash from these accounts, instead of from the tax-deferred ones.

Still Have Questions?

Still unsure about your Medicare and Medicare Supplement choices? You may get in touch with our qualified insurance advisors to determine the best and most cost-effective options that are applicable to your health status, lifestyle and budget. If you already are enrolled in a Medicare Supplement plan and would like further guidance on how to make things more affordable, we can also help. Contact us at (800) 354-1078.